At Stambaugh Jewelers, every piece you bring us is evaluated by our trained staff — using real gem-testing equipment, real diamond grading expertise, and real market knowledge. We buy gold, diamonds, estate jewelry, designer pieces, and fine watches, and we pay fair market value.

The process is straightforward: walk in, or book an appointment, for a no-pressure evaluation. We will examine each piece — testing diamonds with GIA-grade tools, weighing and karat-testing gold, evaluating estate pieces for designer marks, condition, and current market demand — and present you with a written offer that reflects fair market value. Same-day cash payment is available for gold and diamonds. Prefer to trade up? We make an even larger offer toward store credit on a new purchase — meaning the value of what you bring us goes further when applied to your next engagement ring , birthday or anniversary gift, or custom design.

Stambaugh Jewelers has been a trusted name in Downtown Defiance since 1948— with 235+ 5-star reviews from neighbors, families, and clients across Northwest Ohio. Unlike national mail-in services or anonymous storefronts, our buyers are trained professionals you can sit across the table from. Our showroom is a 2,400+ square foot building nestled in the fabric of Downtown Defiance — we are not going anywhere, and the reputation we have built over 78 years is the reason families bring us their grandmother's diamond ring, their father's gold watch, and their own no-longer-worn pieces with confidence.

Simple & Transparent

How The Process Works

Step One
Book an Appointment or Walk In

Simply call or text to schedule an appointment, or stop by our Downtown Defiance showroom. No appointment is required for a free evaluation, but an appointment ensures dedicated time with one of our experienced team members.

Step Two
A Personal Look at Your Jewelry

We’ll take a careful look at your jewelry, gold and diamonds, using the technology and gemological standards needed to understand what you have. We’ll explain what we’re seeing and answer your questions along the way.

Step Three
Receive a Fair, Transparent Offer

Using current market prices and what we’ve learned about your piece, we’ll present you with a clear, fair offer. No pressure. No obligation. If you’d like to think about it, take the time you need. We’ll be here when you’re ready.

Step Four
Get Paid on the Spot — or Get 30% More in Store Credit

If you accept our offer, you can receive payment by cash or check right then and there. Or, choose store credit and receive 30% more value toward any purchase at Stambaugh Jewelers. It’s a great option if you’re ready to turn something you no longer wear into something you’ll love.

You choose what works best for you.